Cooperstown Pins — any team placing an order of at least 1000 pins at 2″ inch size or larger will receive exclusive bonuses. You’ll get a FREE 3′ x 6′ banner. We include 100 special gold metal 2″ inch pins at no additional charge.
Do you remember your first baseball game? The sights, sounds, and excitement create unforgettable memories that often begin with Little League and grow into a lifelong love for the sport. Baseball unites players, families, and fans alike.
At The Pin Creator, we honor this tradition with custom Cooperstown trading pins that capture the spirit of America’s pastime. Each pin is designed to celebrate historic victories, personal milestones, and championship runs—serving as a lasting keepsake for players, coaches, and fans.
Stylish, meaningful, and collectible, our pins preserve memories, spark conversations, and strengthen team pride at every tournament and beyond.
Celebrate every game in style with Cooperstown Trading Pins that turn moments into lasting keepsakes. From championships to friendly matches, our pins highlight your team’s pride on and off the field. While you focus on the game, our pins showcase the identity that brings your team together.
Each custom design is treated like a work of art. Our designers bring your vision to life with precision and multiple quality checks for flawless results. Choose from exciting options like glitter, glow-in-the-dark, sliders, spinners, custom shapes, and enamel finishes to make your pins truly unique.
With The Pin Creator, every pin captures your team’s energy, spirit, and pride—creating memories that last long after the final play.
High Quality: Our custom lapel pins are crafted with precision and attention to detail. We use the finest materials to ensure your pins are not only visually stunning but also durable.
Fast Delivery: Need your custom pins quickly? We’ve got you covered with our fast production and free FedEx Priority Shipping.
Unlimited Revisions: Your satisfaction is our priority. We provide unlimited revisions on all art proofs, so you can make sure your design is just right.
Customization Options: Choose from a variety of materials and plating options to make your custom lapel pins truly unique. Our experts are ready to help you select the options that suit your design.
Minimum Order Size: Whether you need a small quantity or a large batch, we can accommodate your needs. Our minimum order quantity for pins is 100 pieces, and for challenge coins, it’s 50 pieces.
Get a free, no-obligation quote today—just fill out the form, call 855-290-9900, or email sales@thepincreator.com. Our simple process is fast, stress-free, and supported by expert guidance every step of the way.
Our customer service team is ready to answer questions, suggest options, and help finalize your design. Share details like quantity, size, colors, and artwork for the most accurate quote. We’ll also recommend finishes, upgrades, and cost-saving solutions to match your budget.
Whether your order is big or small, we give it the same attention to detail. Reach out today and let’s bring your vision to life—because every great pin starts with a conversation.
For over 30 years, we’ve been a trusted creator of custom sports lapel pins. Our skilled designers craft unique pins tailored to your team’s needs from a wide range of styles.
Choose an idea
First, choose an idea of how you would like to design your pin. You can search for ideas online or visit our pin gallery for inspiration. Also, you can insert your team logo or any specific design and send that to us via the form.
Customize the pin
When you are ready with your idea, come to our website and fill in the order form which is attached to this page. Carefully mention all the requirements and you can upload any pre-designed image as an attachment.
Place the order
Once you have completed the above two steps, click on the submit button to place the order. Your customized lapel pins will be delivered to your doorstep in 10-12 working days. Proof emails will be sent throughout the process.
