- ★★★★★ 5.0 Google Rating
- BBB Accredited Business
- 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
Softball trading pins are one of the most exciting traditions in youth and amateur softball. Whether your team is heading to a Cooperstown Dreams Park tournament, a USSSA regional, or your local league’s end-of-season championship, custom softball pins give players something to trade, collect, and keep forever. At The Pin Creator, we design and produce custom softball trading pins that are built to be shown off and traded — durable, detailed, and delivered fast enough for your 2026 season.
Softball Trading Pins – Any Team ordering 1,000 pins at 2″ or larger receives a FREE 3′ x 6′ banner plus 100 special gold metal 2″ pins at no extra cost. This exclusive offer adds value to your order without increasing price, making it a great way to maximize your benefits.
We specialize exclusively in custom sports trading pins, which means every detail of our process is built around what softball teams actually need: quick turnaround when your tournament date sneaks up on you, low minimum order quantities when your roster is small, and design quality that makes your pins stand out at the trading table.
Not all softball pins are created equal. The Pin Creator offers several pin styles to match your team’s personality and budget:
Standard Softball Trading Pins
Our most popular option. Die-struck or die-cast with soft enamel fill, a butterfly clutch backing, and your full team design. These are the classic trade pins that players love to collect. Available in sizes from 1.25″ to 2.5″.
Glitter and Blink Softball Pins
Want to be the most popular trading table at the tournament? Glitter fill and blinking LED elements make your pins impossible to ignore. These are especially popular for championship and all-star tournament events.
Bobblehead and Spinner Pins
Interactive pins with moving parts — a bobbing player, spinning softball, or dangling charm element. These generate serious buzz at trading events and make outstanding keepsakes.
Dangler Pins
A main pin body with one or more hanging elements on a chain or attachment — perfect for adding extra details like your tournament year, team motto, or mascot.
Every season brings new design trends to the trading pin world. Here is what we are seeing teams order most in 2026:
High Quality: Our custom lapel pins are crafted with precision using premium materials for lasting quality. They are durable, visually striking, and finished to enhance your design. Each pin represents your brand, event, or team with pride.
Fast Delivery: Need your custom pins quickly? We’ve got you covered with our fast production and free FedEx Priority Shipping.
Unlimited Revisions: Your satisfaction is our priority. We provide unlimited revisions on all art proofs, so you can make sure your design is just right.
Customization Options: Choose from a variety of materials and plating options to make your custom lapel pins truly unique. Our experts are ready to help you select the options that suit your design.
Minimum Order Size: Whether you need a small quantity or a large batch, we can accommodate your needs. Our minimum order quantity for pins is 100 pieces, and for challenge coins, it’s 50 pieces.
New to pin trading? Here is what every softball parent and coach should know heading into the 2026 season:
Get a free, no-obligation quote today. Fill out the form on this page, call us toll-free at 855-290-9900, or email sales@thepincreator.com for fast assistance. Our customer service team is ready to guide you and make the process simple and hassle-free.
We utilize state-of-the-art manufacturing processes to create lapel pins that stand out:
Cloisonné:We craft hard enamel pins by adding each color individually, then polish them for a smooth, glass-like finish. The result is a refined, elegant pin with lasting appeal.
Photo Etched: In the photo etched process, we chemically etch the design into the base metal, fill it with color by hand, and then bake it to perfection. A clear epoxy coat can be applied for added protection.
Photo Dome:We print your design on vinyl or paper and apply it to the metal pin base with precise alignment. A clear epoxy dome is added to protect the design, keeping it vibrant and long-lasting.
Screen Printed:With the silk screen process, each color is applied directly to the metal base for bold, solid designs. A thin epoxy coating adds durability and long-lasting protection.
Attachment Options: We offer multiple attachment options, including butterfly clutches, jewelry clutches, safety clasps, magnetic clasps, screws with nuts, and stick pins—giving you flexibility and convenience for any design.
For 30 years, we’ve designed custom pins for sports teams and events, adapting to new styles and trends. Our skilled designers work closely with you to ensure every detail reflects your team’s identity and spirit. The result is a unique, memorable pin that celebrates passion and unity.
Choose an idea
Start by choosing a design idea for your pin. Browse our pin gallery for inspiration or use your team logo or custom artwork. Upload your design through the form to get started.
Customize the pin
When you’re ready, fill out the order form on our website and include all your requirements for accuracy. You can also upload a pre-designed image to help our team bring your vision to life. This ensures the final product matches your expectations.
Place the order
Once you have completed the above two steps, click on the submit button to place the order. Your customized lapel pins will be delivered to your doorstep in 10-12 working days. Proof emails will be sent throughout the process.
Softball trading pins are custom collectible pins that teams create to trade with other teams at tournaments and events. Each team designs their own unique pin featuring their team name, mascot, colors, and year, then trades them with players from other teams as a sportsmanship and community tradition. The more creative and unique the pin, the more sought-after it becomes for trading.
Most teams order between 50 and 150 pins per season, depending on the number of tournaments they attend and roster size. A good rule of thumb is to order 2 to 3 pins per player for each major tournament you attend, plus extra for coaches, team families, and unexpected trading opportunities. If you are attending a large national tournament like Cooperstown, order more — pin trading is very active at those events.
Custom softball trading pins typically range from $2.50 to $6.00 per pin depending on the size, style, and quantity ordered. Standard die-cast pins are at the lower end of that range, while specialty pins with blinking lights, glitter, danglers, or moving parts are priced higher. The Pin Creator provides free quotes and digital proofs before you commit to an order.
Standard production time is 12 to 15 business days after design approval, with shipping on top of that. Rush options are available that can reduce production to 7 to 10 business days. If you have a tournament coming up, contact us as early as possible — ideally 4 to 6 weeks before your event — to ensure comfortable delivery timing.
Yes. The Pin Creator offers softball trading pins with no strict minimum order requirement. Whether you need 25 pins for a small travel team or 500 pins for a large tournament organization, we can accommodate your order. Pricing per pin improves with larger quantities, so ordering more when possible is a good investment.
The most popular softball trading pin styles in 2026 are spinner pins, glitter and blink pins, and dangler pins with multiple hanging elements. Standard soft enamel pins remain the most common for teams on a budget, while teams looking to win ‘best pin at the tournament’ typically choose blinker or dangler styles.
